Who do you want to see as a new HC?....Part II
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2015 2:14 pm
Since the last discussion of HC candidates essentially went "off the rails", let's start a new one. I ask that everyone try to keep discussions limited to actual candidates that you'd like to see, qualifications you want the coach to have, etc. Same poll as before, minus the "Hire internally" option, since it looks like that's likely not a possibility at this point.
I'll go ahead and start things up with some of the people who's names I've seen mentioned either on this forum or on twitter, along with a brief description of their qualifications. Feel free to agree with any of them, add your own candidates, or whatever. Obviously, all of this would be contingent upon their interest level...Western (and Illinois in general) right now is a rather "tough sell" for most people.
Who's been mentioned so far:
Jeff Hecklinski - currently QB/Passing Game Coach/Coordinator at CSU-Pueblo (Div. II)
Wikipedia (link above) has his full bio, but for those that don't know, Hecklinski is probably within the top 5 of the best QBs we've had at Western (started '95-'97). QB/WR/Offensive coach at various schools...NAIA, NJCAA, Div. II. Moved right up to FBS level as QB/passing game coach at Arizona. Joined Brady Hoke as WR coach at Ball State, followed Hoke to San Diego State (assistant HC and RBs there), then to Michigan (WR coach there). After Hoke and staff were let go at Michigan, went to be QB/Passing game coach at CSU-Pueblo (Div. II, but one of the best Div. II schools out there...won Div. II championship last year, made it deep in playoffs this year).
Pros - lots of experience at essentially all levels of college football, knows the school and the area very well (Western grad and Chicago-area guy), recognizable name for anyone who was at Western in the late '90s
Cons - technically no HC experience
Glenn Caruso - HC at St. Thomas (Div. III)
Played at Ithaca College, assistant or coordinator at NDSU, UW-Eau Claire, and South Dakota, HC at Macalester (Div. III) for 2 years, then HC at St. Thomas (also Div. III) for 8 years. Is 80-13 as HC at St. Thomas, with 1 Div. III championship (2012) and is playing in championship game again this year this coming Friday evening.
Pros - success as HC, playoff/championship game experience, has coached at a couple of other MVFC programs, so would be familiar with some of the competition
Cons - HC experience all at Div. III level, little to no scholarship management experience, supposedly well-paid for the level of his position (private school...plenty of $) with successful program and nice facilities.
Matt Entz - DC at NDSU
Coached around Div. II for a while, was D-line coach at UNI for 3 years, Associate HC/Co-Def Coord/D-line coach at Western for 1 year, Defensive Coordinator/Linebackers at NDSU for 2 years.
Pros - knows Western and the area, knows the conference very well, excellent defensive coach
Cons - no HC experience
Adam Dorrel - HC at NW Missouri State (Div. II)
Played at NW MO State. Grad assistant at NW MO State for a year, O-Line Coach at Dakota State (NAIA), Assistant Coach at William Jewell (Div. II), Assistant Coach at NW MO State, HC at NW MO State (60-8 record) for 5 years.
Pros - Great success at head coach, familiar with the midwest area.
Cons - Bleeds Bearcat green and white, already HC at a successful program with great support and facilities (so, near impossible to wrestle him away), also no Div. I experience.
Frisman Jackson - current WR coach at Temple University
Like Hecklinski, successful player at Western (after transferring from Northern IL) from the Chicago area...was both QB and WR at times. Played 6 years in NFL with Browns and Jets.
WR coach at Western for two years, Akron for 2 years, Northern IL for 1 year, NC State for 2 years, and Temple for 1 year.
Pros - knows the school and the area, recognizable name for anyone at Western in the early '00s, experience at FCS and FBS levels
Cons - coaching experience limited to WRs, no HC experience
I'll go ahead and start things up with some of the people who's names I've seen mentioned either on this forum or on twitter, along with a brief description of their qualifications. Feel free to agree with any of them, add your own candidates, or whatever. Obviously, all of this would be contingent upon their interest level...Western (and Illinois in general) right now is a rather "tough sell" for most people.
Who's been mentioned so far:
Jeff Hecklinski - currently QB/Passing Game Coach/Coordinator at CSU-Pueblo (Div. II)
Wikipedia (link above) has his full bio, but for those that don't know, Hecklinski is probably within the top 5 of the best QBs we've had at Western (started '95-'97). QB/WR/Offensive coach at various schools...NAIA, NJCAA, Div. II. Moved right up to FBS level as QB/passing game coach at Arizona. Joined Brady Hoke as WR coach at Ball State, followed Hoke to San Diego State (assistant HC and RBs there), then to Michigan (WR coach there). After Hoke and staff were let go at Michigan, went to be QB/Passing game coach at CSU-Pueblo (Div. II, but one of the best Div. II schools out there...won Div. II championship last year, made it deep in playoffs this year).
Pros - lots of experience at essentially all levels of college football, knows the school and the area very well (Western grad and Chicago-area guy), recognizable name for anyone who was at Western in the late '90s
Cons - technically no HC experience
Glenn Caruso - HC at St. Thomas (Div. III)
Played at Ithaca College, assistant or coordinator at NDSU, UW-Eau Claire, and South Dakota, HC at Macalester (Div. III) for 2 years, then HC at St. Thomas (also Div. III) for 8 years. Is 80-13 as HC at St. Thomas, with 1 Div. III championship (2012) and is playing in championship game again this year this coming Friday evening.
Pros - success as HC, playoff/championship game experience, has coached at a couple of other MVFC programs, so would be familiar with some of the competition
Cons - HC experience all at Div. III level, little to no scholarship management experience, supposedly well-paid for the level of his position (private school...plenty of $) with successful program and nice facilities.
Matt Entz - DC at NDSU
Coached around Div. II for a while, was D-line coach at UNI for 3 years, Associate HC/Co-Def Coord/D-line coach at Western for 1 year, Defensive Coordinator/Linebackers at NDSU for 2 years.
Pros - knows Western and the area, knows the conference very well, excellent defensive coach
Cons - no HC experience
Adam Dorrel - HC at NW Missouri State (Div. II)
Played at NW MO State. Grad assistant at NW MO State for a year, O-Line Coach at Dakota State (NAIA), Assistant Coach at William Jewell (Div. II), Assistant Coach at NW MO State, HC at NW MO State (60-8 record) for 5 years.
Pros - Great success at head coach, familiar with the midwest area.
Cons - Bleeds Bearcat green and white, already HC at a successful program with great support and facilities (so, near impossible to wrestle him away), also no Div. I experience.
Frisman Jackson - current WR coach at Temple University
Like Hecklinski, successful player at Western (after transferring from Northern IL) from the Chicago area...was both QB and WR at times. Played 6 years in NFL with Browns and Jets.
WR coach at Western for two years, Akron for 2 years, Northern IL for 1 year, NC State for 2 years, and Temple for 1 year.
Pros - knows the school and the area, recognizable name for anyone at Western in the early '00s, experience at FCS and FBS levels
Cons - coaching experience limited to WRs, no HC experience